Trivium
Curriculum/Plato's Republic: What is Justice?/Capstone Essay: Is Thrasymachus Right?
Plato's Republic: What is Justice?Grade 9rhetoric Stage

Capstone Essay: Is Thrasymachus Right?

Capstone essay synthesizing the unit. Students write a formal argumentative essay responding to the prompt: "Is Thrasymachus right that justice is merely the advantage of the stronger? Use evidence from the Republic to make your argument."

The Text

What You'll Learn

1

Thesis

States a clear, arguable thesis in response to the prompt

2

Evidence

Cites specific passages from the Republic to support the argument

3

Analysis

Explains how the evidence supports the thesis

4

Counterargument

Acknowledges and responds to the strongest opposing view

5

Synthesis

Connects the argument to broader themes or other thinkers

6

Clarity

Well-organized, grammatically sound, clear prose

How It Works

Your AI tutor will guide you through this text using the Socratic method. Instead of giving you answers, it asks questions that help you discover the meaning for yourself.

  • 1.Read the text carefully
  • 2.Answer the tutor's questions in your own words
  • 3.Progress through each stage as you demonstrate understanding
Start This Lesson

Free to try. No credit card required.