Plutarch: LivesGrade 8dialectic Stage

Alcibiades

Alcibiades was the most brilliant and beautiful Athenian of his age - and the most destructive. Raised by Pericles after his father died, beloved by Socrates, he had every advantage. But his beauty and charm masked an insatiable ambition and total lack of moral anchor. As a child, he bit an opponent in wrestling "like a lion." He refused to play the flute because it would distort his beautiful face. Socrates loved him and tried to guide him, but Alcibiades resisted philosophy's discipline. He defected to Sparta, then to Persia, then back to Athens, always serving his own ambition. He died in exile, assassinated by enemies.

The Text

What You'll Learn

1

Comprehension

Recalls Alcibiades' famous beauty and charm that lasted his whole life

2

Cause & Consequence

Explains what Plutarch says about his ambition: "the most prevailing of all" his passions

3

Meaning

Engages with the question: What good is talent without virtue?

4

Evidence

Cites a specific passage or phrase from the text

5

Defense

Maintains or thoughtfully revises their position under challenge

How It Works

Your AI tutor will guide you through this text using the Socratic method. Instead of giving you answers, it asks questions that help you discover the meaning for yourself.

  • 1.Read the text carefully
  • 2.Answer the tutor's questions in your own words
  • 3.Progress through each stage as you demonstrate understanding
Start This Lesson

Free to try. No credit card required.